What happens to a MaxieDISC® profile when the same person retakes the test years later.
Heraclitus claimed that you cannot step into the same river twice — because the second time both the water is different and we are different. It’s usually quoted as a line about impermanence. But it has a second layer that I like more: the river is, nevertheless, the same river. Entirely different water flows through it, and yet we call it by its name without hesitation.
Recently I asked myself a question of the same weight, only less poetic. A person who fills in MaxieDISC® today — will they get the same result in a year? In two years? In seven?
It turned out I had the means to check. The database held 193 people who had completed the test at least twice — sometimes on the same day, sometimes more than seven years apart; the median interval was 284 days, well over nine months. I compared their first and last attempt for the natural style.
Let me make one caveat right away, because it’s honest and important: this was not a planned study under laboratory conditions. These people decided for themselves when and why to return to the test. So every figure below should be read as a lower-bound estimate of the tool’s consistency — under cleaner conditions it would be better.
What the numbers say — how similar the profiles are to each other
The agreement of two measurements is captured by the ICC coefficient. Put simply: 1.0 is perfect repeatability, 0 is pure chance. The accepted thresholds say that 0.50–0.75 is moderate agreement, and above 0.75 — good. Here is what came out for the four dimensions:
| Dimension | ICC | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Conscientious (C) | 0.71 | moderate, close to good |
| Influencing (I) | 0.64 | moderate |
| Dominant (D) | 0.62 | moderate |
| Steady (S) | 0.50 | on the border of weak and moderate |
All four dimensions agree to a moderate degree — Conscientiousness holds up best, Steadiness the weakest. And here’s a curiosity that shows how carefully such tables must be read: Steadiness has the lowest coefficient while, in absolute terms, it changes the least of all the dimensions (on average 12.6 points, against ~16 for D and I).
So why does it come out „weakest”? Because in this sample the S scores are exceptionally high and have little spread — many people have 90–100%, and from there you can only move downward. A low coefficient here doesn’t mean „worse measurement”, only „differentiates people less”. It’s a good lesson in humility toward a single number.
How time affects the stability of the natural style
The most important result is the least spectacular, so I’ll say it straight away: time does not blur the profile.
If a MaxieDISC® result were merely a snapshot of a momentary mood, agreement should weaken as the months pass. The opposite happens. People who returned to the test after more than a year (some after two or three years) agree with themselves just as well or better than those from a few months earlier — for Conscientiousness the ICC reaches 0.80 in this group, for Influence 0.75, the highest in the whole analysis. The statistics close it off drily: the relationship between the length of the gap and the size of the change is, in practice, zero (ρ = −0.05).
This is exactly that Heraclitean river. The water has been replaced — and we still know which way it flows and what it’s called.
How the dominant style changes
There is a number in this data that is easy to tell wrongly. The dominant style — that first letter most people remember from their report — stayed the same for exactly 49% of people (for 94 of 193). Stated bluntly, it sounds like an accusation: your test shows something different for half of people?
And then you look at how that letter changes — and the whole story turns around.
Of the 99 people whose first letter changed, for 87% the new dominant style was already present in the first profile, and for two-thirds it was the second letter in it. Almost no one „jumps” to a style that wasn’t there before. The changes follow well-worn paths: most often Steadiness and Conscientiousness swap places, sometimes Steadiness gives way to Dominance. A transition between Influence and Conscientiousness? One case in 65 people. What changes is usually the order of the two highest dimensions, not a shift in a completely different direction.
And here we reach what I consider the most important lesson of the whole analysis. For most people, the single dominant style is not a lone leader at all. For 64% of those studied, the difference between the two highest dimensions was at most 10 points.
For 19% — one person in five — the two highest dimensions were exactly equal. If two values almost touch, it’s natural that on the next measurement they’ll swap places. This is not instability in the person. It’s the honesty of an instrument that doesn’t pretend to see a difference where there is almost none. (Tellingly: when the highest dimension had a clear lead — at least 15 points — it held up for 57% of people, not 43–47%.)
So the stable thing is not the profile’s dominant style. The stable thing is the whole profile — the set of styles that rise within a person. And that is what should be read. This is also why we teach our consultants to recognize these nuances and to understand more than single styles alone.
A practical moral for anyone sitting down with a report
From all of this come very concrete conclusions — both for consultants and for the people who receive their result:
First, small differences between two assessments are not a change. To conclude that a score has really shifted — and not just rippled within the margin of measurement — the difference in a single dimension must exceed roughly 35–40 points. Anything below that is noise, even if it looks significant.
Second, if your two highest letters are close together, your profile is the whole profile — and it’s worth thinking about yourself that way. Not „I have style S”, but „my behavior is characterized by the presence of styles S and C, with S slightly ahead”. That’s a very concrete difference.
Third — and this is the principle I repeat most often: a style is a hypothesis, not a diagnosis. A MaxieDISC® report is a picture of preferences at a given moment, an invitation to a conversation about yourself, not a label stuck on permanently.
DISC describes certain tendencies; it is a starting point for working on yourself and for conversation. No style tells you who you will become or what you will achieve.
Let’s sum up
Numerically, the stability of MaxieDISC® under these conditions is moderate — and that’s what I call it, without embellishment. But „moderate, measured after nine months, in people who chose the moment of return themselves, and independent nonetheless of whether a year or seven years had passed” is something entirely different from „shaky”. It’s a profile that stays with a person for years, shifting at most by a neighbouring note.
So let’s go back to the bank. You are not the same person you were two years ago — Heraclitus was right, the water has been replaced.
And yet, when you fill in the same test years later, it still yields a recognizably identical profile. A good profile is exactly like that: flexible enough to admit that you are changing, and durable enough to still know what the core of your behavioral style is.